How Much Should Contractors Mark Up Materials? Why I Charge 30%

In my last post, I wrote about underbidding labor because of how I felt about a customer. Materials were the same problem, just quieter. For a long time I was paying for part of my customers’ jobs out of my own pocket, one tube of silicone at a time.

The stuff I wasn’t charging for

When I bid a job, I’d price the big materials: the door, the trim. The small stuff I’d just cover. Caulk, silicone, expanding foam around the jamb, specialty fasteners I don’t normally keep on hand. Sometimes extra trim I didn’t expect to need when I first bid the job.

And when I did bid materials, I added the sales tax but not a markup. I figured all of it by hand, or tried to remember to put it in the spreadsheet.

Where it cost me

Masonry doors. I’d put a masonry install on the bid, but not the Tapcon screws or the masonry bits. On some houses I could drill every hole with a used bit. On others I’d hit rebar or a hard piece of aggregate I couldn’t see, ruin the bit, move the hole, and start over. I’ve gone through 3 or 4 bits installing one door.

A TV lift. I thought I had fasteners that would work. I didn’t. I needed GRK RSS structural screws, about a dollar each, and used half a box on that one job. That time, I worked out what each screw cost me and added that many screws to the job.

The second tube. I’d estimate one tube of silicone under the threshold and need two. One can of OSI Quad foam around the jamb, and need two. I keep extra cans in the truck for exactly that reason, but I didn’t always charge for them. That’s bidding with my feelings again.

How I handle materials now

  • Job-specific consumables go on the job as line items: caulk, silicone, foam, specialty fasteners, even drill bits. The ones I use all the time live in my materials catalog, with prices for specific stores. If the closest store to the job is a Lowe’s, I bid with that store’s prices.

  • Big jobs get a “shop materials” line. On a big trim or cabinet job that goes through a lot of sandpaper and small supplies, one line covers it all.

  • Extras get billed. If a job needed something I didn’t plan for, it goes on the invoice. I rarely get pushback. People understand that the materials went into their home.

  • Big changes get a change order. If the job needs significantly more material or work than expected, I write a change order, the customer approves it, and then it’s added to the job.

Why 30% markup

Markup isn’t free money. It pays for real work:

  • planning what the job needs

  • checking prices across stores

  • driving to the store, shopping, checking out, and loading up

  • hauling it all to the job site

  • prices that change between the day I estimate and the day the job starts

  • that second tube of silicone I didn’t see coming

I started at 20% when I went out on my own, and the margins were too thin. My dad is a general contractor and uses 50%, but he carries more liability and higher overhead than I do. For me, 30% covers the work. Your number depends on your own overhead, but if you’re not marking up materials at all, you’re running errands for your customers for free.

I add sales tax on top. The rules for contractors and sales tax vary by state, so check yours.

“Can I just buy the materials myself?”

Usually, yes. My answer is: OK, have the exact material I specified on site when I’m ready to start. I send a shopping list with the estimate, and when I get there, I check everything against it. If something’s wrong or missing, we know before I start, not halfway through.

There are exceptions. Lumber, trim, and plywood, I pick myself. Most homeowners grab whatever’s on top of the stack without checking whether it’s straight, twisted, bowed, or damaged. If I’m installing it, I need it right.

And I don’t use MDF. Almost never. My estimates call for solid wood or finger-jointed material. When a customer asks if I can use MDF because it’s cheaper, I tell them no, and why. Either they accept the difference or they hire someone else, and I’m fine with either one.

On warranty: I warranty my labor. Materials are covered by the manufacturer’s warranty, and if a product has to be finished a certain way for that warranty to hold, I tell the customer up front.

You can do this without an app

  1. List the consumables each type of job really uses, including the small stuff.

  2. Pick a markup and put it on every material line, every time.

  3. Bill the second tube. If it went into their house, it goes on the invoice.

  4. Write a change order when the job changes, before you do the extra work.

Where BuiltWright comes in

BuiltWright has a materials catalog with your cost, your markup, and the stores you buy from. Add a material to an estimate and the markup and sales tax are added automatically. Point your phone’s camera at a shelf tag and it fills in the entry. And the shopping list adds up the same material across a job and rounds to whole pieces, so a six-door job doesn’t list the same trim stick six times. You can try it in the free demo, with no account needed.

Next up: the paperwork. Notes on my phone, a spreadsheet, a Word document, and formatting it all by hand every single time.

Next
Next

Price the Task, Not the Customer: How I Stopped Underbidding Jobs